Wakeman....you've worked tirelessly on this project and plz see the good that has come out of what u've done. There will always be ppl who are too arrogant to see that they can always learn something. But, overall, i think most ppl were receptive and did make positive changes. Even if it wasn't to the letter. Also, please know we all appreciate everything you've done to keep it going. I personally apologize for being so scarce here lately. I just really needed a break.

I would agree, that this endeavor didnt go as we would have liked. BUT....I do still see a benefit from it. I really do think it is a great way to get new players acclimated into the guild, encourages ppl to sign up on forums, and even if we dont go into in-depth analysis on their toon, we familiarize ourselves with that persons capabilities/limitations. We do, however, need more ppl to look after the threads and make sure they are responded to. JMHO
As far as the ppl who did not receive their dkp...im not 100% sure. I went through the dkp as it is now (i know we are in the process of maually inputing some dkp, due to a problem loading the lua file to the site) and these are the ppl i see that have not received their dkp:
Cyclop (like he needs it)
Fraker
Artisa
Findit
Bigdug (was awhile ago, but i dont see him receiving his dkp)